The Gran Varones is a storytelling project that uses video and photography for Latino Gay and Latino Queer* men. Inspired by Willie Colon’s groundbreaking song “El Gran Varòn,” this project shines a light on what being “out” and “proud” means to us.
on friday, april 17, 2015, gran varones creator louie a. ortiz was invited to speak at a press conference at city hall about the exclusion of latino lgbtq immigrants in the presidential immigration relief action. here is his speech:
My name is Louie A. Ortiz, creator of the Gran Varones, a multi-media project that shines light on Latino queer communities. Like many other Latino LGBTQ people in our communities, I am a parent. I am the sole provider for my son. I do not have complete legal custody of my child and someone in my shoes could be separated from their family if we are not included in the protection DACA and DAPA provides. While this presidential action will provide relief for members in our community, many will be excluded.
This Presidential action is only a first step. Any immigration benefit derived from the “traditional” idea of family, leaves out many LGBTQ people in our community whose families are frequently not recognized under the law. Policies are needed to recognize families similar to mine.
These kinds of exclusions continue to leave LGBTQ people at risk of being detained in jails that are incredibly unsafe and inhumane, particularly for transgender women who continue to be detained with men. LGBTQ Latinos are mothers, fathers, brothers, sisters and leaders in our communities. It is our commitment to advocate for wide-ranging policies that ensure that everyone is included in this protection so that families similar to mine are not torn apart. #Not1Mo
I decided to send you an email to express something that has been in my head for a couple of days. I must say that I doubted whether I should address this with you and I tried to ignore it, why? Well, first, because it is always difficult to address this issue and second because I did not want to accept that I am a target of oppression.
Since the first time we met, I realized, you have confused me with the other person of color in class. At first, I thought that it would be a very normal thing to do since having new class represents meeting new people. Learning new names is always a challenge. As the classes continued I have seen you articulating my clasemates’ names. It seemed that you have been able to connect a name with each of their faces. Then, I saw you using my name to ask the other person of color to read in class. It has happened more then twice already. I asked myself: “Why is it that my professor is able to learn the names of all the other students but not the name of the two of us?“
I must say that my mind started to work harder to understand this but maybe I just did not want to see it in the beginning. I have heard many stories of people of color who have experienced the same dynamic with their names in different contexts. It seems that these interactions happens when the majority of people that they work or go to school with are white. It seems that for white teachers, classmates or co-workers it is hard to learn the names of people of color they have around. As we know, there is a history in USA that normalized European and Anglicized names and pathologized non-white names.
There is so much evidence that shows the negative effects that people of color struggle with in society, such as discrimination and violence in school, work and neighborhoods. Mistaking the names of people of color displays a microaggression that assumes that all people of color look the same and we do not deserve an individual identity.
People of color’s name are important because there is always a story that unveils our family traditions, identity, culture, etc. Our names are connected to our stories, stories that were stolen from us from slavery or colonization. This is how trans-generational trauma is inherited and reinforced by people who benefit from whiteness.
My intention behind this email is to resist. I refuse to accept this oppression, I refuse to sit and let other generations normalize this behavior. I resist whiteness and all those who benefit from it. I resist being located in a space where my identities are condemned to be invisible. I resist accepting that I need to educate highly educated and privilege people.
I refuse to not hear my name; I am committed to naming a racist behavior or a micro aggression. I deserve to have individual humanity.
I decide to name the racist behavior. I decide to name what it is hard to name. I decide to name what nobody else wants to name. I resist in the hopes that this behavior will not continue into the next generation.
I am a Mexican American, Latino, gay, queer, bilingual, immigrant, man of color, social worker, citizen, and human being who claims his individuality and loves being connected to different communities that empower me.
I believe apologies are important, but I do not need one because at the end actions are stronger than words. I have received many apologies from white people about their microaggressions, but even if the intentions were good, it seems that the main goal was just get rid of white guilt. I cannot do that, not because I think they do not deserve forgiveness but because the risk to engage in an endless vicious circle is strong. I believe privilege makes people insensitive; exposing them to this pain is constructive for both sides. Here is the point where white allies are born.
And me, I am not upset anymore. I am interested in finding my own healing.
Sinceramente,
Luis Ramirez
Luis is a therapist, advocate, singer and varòn from Philadelphia.
Louie: Describe the first time you fell in love with a man.
Juan: I was living in Connecticut. It was with someone who was visiting
Connecticut for a few weeks, We met and hung out everyday until he had
to leave. It was scary but in the initial stages of it, I didn’t
realize that I was scared. I just felt excited. I’d finally made a
connection with someone, that connection that I had always heard
about, that I had talked about. I always forced [that connection] with a lot of girls I dated because I was in the “closet” and terrified to come
out.
So after dating so many girls, I was tired of looking
for something I was trying to force and being young when it started
happening, it happened fast. It was a feeling that I have never
experienced. It felt great. Whenever I was with him, it felt great. When
he left, I felt scared and unprepared for that feeling. I didn’t know
how to handle it. It was also my first heartbreak.
Juan David Franco, Philadelphia Interviewed by: Louie A. Ortiz-Fonseca
“Caminando, mirando una
estrella.Walking, looking at a star Caminando, oyendo una voz. Walking, listening to a voice Caminando, siguiendo la
huella, Walking,
following a footstep Caminando, que otro camino. Walking the
path]that someone else walked Caminando, buscando a la vida. Walking,
searching for life Caminando, buscando al amor. Walking,
looking for love Caminando,
curando la herida, Walking,
healing the wound Caminando, que deja el dolor! Walking, to leave
the pain behind” - Rubén Blades
I still get nervous walking down streets alone. Or when I walk into a
barbershop. Or while I am just fucking walking and minding my business. There
is a part of me that still telling me to hold my breath and brace my spirit for
the sound of the word “faggot.” Sometimes, it doesn’t even have to be spoken. People
can say it with their eyes. This is why I still hold my breath whenever I am
walking.
I saw you and your friends as we crossed the street. My friends and I
were coming from the opening rally of the Philly Trans* March. We were feeling
inspired. We were also feeling angry that yet another black trans* woman had
been murdered, this time in our city. We were walking with that weighing heavy on
our minds and hearts.
You and your 4 friends glanced at us; all of you, black and brown,
reminding me of my 13 year old son. I could see the curiosity in your eyes. I
could see the smirk creeping across your face as you noticed that one of us had
on skinny jeans and two of us were holding hands. I could feel the jokes formulating in your minds, sense the
giggles about to burst from your lips. I saw it and I looked away hoping you
would make a different decision.
As my friends and I chatted about the best way to meet up with the Trans*
March, one of you shouted “Ewww you’re gay!” I am not sure whose lips spewed
those words but I know exactly where the hell they landed. My first instinct
was to go off but instead, I said aloud “Black and Brown lives matter. Right
now, even in this moment.”
As we continued walking, we heard a voice shout “Which one of you is the guy?” Implying that one of us was less than a man because of who you assumed
we were. We heard you laugh that laugh that communicated “Ha! Faggot!”
We kept walking. We nervously laughed it off. I was burning on the
inside. I was trying to manage my anger. I was doing a great a job too – until
you approached us, from behind, on your bikes. I was blind with rage and I let
ya’ll know, loud and clear:
“I dare y’all to say that shit to
my face. I will smack your ass off of that damn bike. I dare you!”
Y’all looked taken aback, as if you were taught that harassing men like
us was okay, maybe even the “normal” thing to do. But clearly you missed the
lesson on our refusal to stay silent.
You surrounded us on your bikes. I was too enraged to even notice that
we stumbled into a wedding party of white folks posing for photos. I approached
y’all and shouted “Why would you wanna make someone feel bad on purpose? Why
would you want to do that?”
You stood silent as if you were just now realizing that your words
actually had power—the power to make grown-ups feels like shit. All of your
faces reminded me of my son. All of your faces reminded me I was a father. The
space fell silent. I stood still, quietly re-evaluating my approach. I knew then that a bridge was going to be
built, however painful, and this bridge was going to get us BOTH across what
felt like an endless divide.
“Keep it down. Can’t you see they are trying to take wedding photos?
And why are you trying to make them [the teens] feel bad?”
You and your friends heard this uninformed, self-entitled scolding
dished out from a passerby as a permission slip. You felt, as the silence
broke, suddenly empowered to call us faggots as you got back on your bikes and
road away. The white woman kept shouting as she walked away, cheering you and
your friends on.
You may not have noticed that an entire wedding party of white people was not
only laughing at ALL OF US but also filming and snapchatting the scene as we
stood there, utterly horrified and dehumanized. It was clear that the white
woman who cheered you on would have rather seen us called faggots than see black
and brown people try to heal and build community. You may not have noticed that the entire wedding party of white people literally laugh at our expense – at the
expense of a group of black and brown folks. These are the very same white
folks who, any other day, would have clutched their purses and phones if y’all
had approached them on the street.
I walked away returning to the march feeling a tremendous loss, of not only
my temper and composure, but a loss of a piece of my humanity. Truly, a loss of connection, both as an elder
and father.
My screaming and shouting will never be the motivation you and your
friends need to make a different decision. My shouting will only teach you all not to get
caught teasing people. That was not the lesson I wanted to share that day. I
wanted to say “You hurt me. You embarrassed me. Your words hold all the weight
in the world because you are the world.” I wanted to remind you that all those
who were laughing at us will laugh at you soon. That really, we are not so
different, and that we are united in a greater struggle. That this petty hatred
will tear us apart. That it is in these very moments, when toxic messages of
socialized hate show up within our own “families”, we must remember love.
I wanted to take back every word. I wanted to replace every “I would
smack the hell out of you” to “I will love you harder because that is what we
MUST all do.” I wanted to tell you that my heart was broken and you had the
power and opportunity to provide healing. But white supremacy and homophobia
prevented that.
I want you to know that you and I tried. I know you did because y’all
stopped riding your bikes and gave me the floor to speak. I wish our few
moments together were different. But we
don’t always get second chances. We don’t get to undo trauma. We simply get to
process and move on – if we are lucky.
Yesterday, as my son and I walked around in the super market, I told
him this story. His immediate response was “I wish I were there because…” I
stopped him and said “Baby, you were. Those kids were young teens, just like
you. They were beautiful just like you. They were all coming into an
understanding of their power just like you.” He looked puzzled for a few
moments and then said, “Maybe no one told them that teasing people is wrong.
Maybe they forgot that ALL black lives matter, even you and your friends.” Then, he took my hand in his, and we walked.
Danny Pintauro is the type of person I cannot stand in the advocate/activist field. I have heard about other people who seem to speak without thought. “They mean well. They’re new to this work. They just need to be taught.” Fuck that. If someone chooses to be a representative for any cause, it would be in their best interest and the best interest of their cause for them to, maybe, I don’t know, do some research. Read a few articles or studies. Watch a documentary or interview.
Before I hear “He didn’t choose this. He disclosed and people started asking him those questions.” He accepted that chat with Oprah. He accepted that sit down with those morons on The View. He accepted that magazine interview. He is accepting each appearance he is making and without preparation. Pintauro has set our community back. Science is science. Oral transmission of HIV has never been reported. Oral sex is referenced as a “safer” option when having condomless sex. Many of us who work in this industry are trained with this knowledge. Trained to offer oral sex over penetrative sex as an option to folks, who may not use condoms for whatever reason, to reduce the risk of HIV transmission. So when Danny, an HIV positive person (that gives him ALL the merit in the world), says that he was infected by oral sex and that “It’s that easy.” He kinda messes it up for a lot of us.
Like those of us who may be in a magnetic relationship with a partner whose mother is afraid of you ruining her child’s life. Or those of us who are beaten or murdered because we failed to disclose our undetectable status to someone we used a condom with. Or those of us who are jailed because we are diseased and dangerous to the public. Because, it’s that easy. The logic for someone who only knows what they hear on television about HIV will probably be, “It’s as easy as a blowjob to get HIV. So any other sexual activity is probably way more dangerous.”
I have been asked time and time again if I know how I got it or who gave it to me. I don’t, nor do I care. I don’t care because it’s not conducive to my health. Because it won’t change my status. I don’t care because there’s no point in assigning blame to anyone for being HIV positive. I think the only reason I’d like to know would be to make sure that person did find out their status and is in good health. Which is allegedly what Pintauro wants. Except for the fact that he went on to say about the man he thinks infected him “The lifestyle he was leading was really irresponsible.” What? I understand that substance abuse is a bitch. Believe me. But if I was high off my ass and putting myself at risk at the same time with someone, I would not say “Dude was super reckless. Not me.” This was an attempt to make the audience view Danny as an innocent victim who got “the AIDS” because of “the gay lifestyle”. I’m all for a good consensual, anonymous bareback session. Live your life be happy, but when you toss drugs into the mix there are some factors of risk that you may want to consider. Risks that you accept with or without inhibitions. I’ve taken some of those risks that could very well be the reason I sero-converted, however, I have never felt the need to defend how I was infected. I’m not sorry that I am positive. No one should be.
Danny owes an apology to everyone. I am personally pissed off because I’ve sat through terribly dehumanizing conversations trying to help people understand that I am not dangerous. We work so hard to improve not only the quality of health for those with HIV but the quality of life as well.
Danny Pintauro got bored of managing a PF Changs and now wants to be a poster boy. That’s fine and dandy, Danny. Just do the work and the research.
written by: Adrian Castellanos
Adrian Castellanos is a twenty-three year old HIV and AIDS advocate/activist. He was born and raised in the southern-most part of Texas known as the Rio Grande Valley. A border area of Texas to Mexico and South Padre Island.
Adrian studied art and fashion for a brief amount of time in Texas before he moved on to becoming a hair stylist in his home town.
At twenty one, Castellanos’ path was redirected as he was diagnosed with AIDS, while he spent two weeks in a hospital room, he decided to “make his mess his message”. Since being diagnosed on March 26, 2014 he has gone on to receive a Youth Initiative Scholarship to attend USCA in OCT. 2014, acquire a position with the Valley AIDS Council (the only HIV/AIDS Agency in his area) JAN. 2015, receive a separate scholarship to attend AIDSWatch in APR. 2015 and receive a Social Media Fellows Scholarship to USCA 2015. Adrian now spends his time doing free HIV screenings at two universities in his area and for the community with his agency. He also participates in outreach and education efforts to raise awareness within his community.
Castellanos utilizes social media to deconstruct stigma and engage with as many people as possible. He is just out of his first year of diagnoses but already has a strong outlook on what he plans to do for the fight to end the epidemic.
You can follow Adrian at: facebook.com/aydenplus Twitter.com/_ayden_plus
qpoc: stonewall reinforced white supremacy by erasing qpoc
white gays: calm down! let’s wait to see the entire movie
*reviews come out*
white gays: ok. now we believe you.
Louie: Describe the moment you know unequivocally that you were gay?
Adrian: My family used to go to the mall a lot when I was little. I realized I was staring into the Abercrombie window more than the Victoria’s Secret window. And then the men and not the women who were passing by us. I knew I liked boys and the way they made me feel. I was probably 10.
Louie: We have met several varones who have recently been diagnosed, all of them while in the hospital. Many of them are afraid of the stigma that they will unfortunately and inevitably experience. What would you want them to know about the journey of living with HIV?
Adrian: I’d want them to know that they’re not alone. When I went to my first conference (USCA2014) only a few months after I was diagnosed, I saw this huge community. I’m not talking about the pharmaceutical reps and doctors. I’m talking about the advocates. People that were where I was. People my age. Latinx people. Like, I was very fortunate to have a support system. And that’s part of why I got into this work. I want to be there for that person that might not have anyone. Because I get it. I know how uncomfortable that hospital bed is. And I know how scary it is to disclose to someone for the first time. Can we start a big sibling project for newly diagnosed folks? Lol
Louie: Who is the person that got you through your most difficult time?
Adrian: Oh man, my mama. She’s the MVP, almost literally ride or die. When I collapsed she got me into the car and drove me to the hospital. She hates driving at night. She refused to leave my side in the hospital. She’s literally the first person I told. Why are you trying to make me cry? Lol Yeah my mom. I had just left my ex too. She got me through all that. When I was on bed rest for a month after the hospital she was there every second. We were going through a lot with my dad at that time too. I’ve never met anyone more resilient in my life. She’s literally a goddess.
Adrian Castellanos, Rio Grande Valley, Texas AIDS Activist, Blogger and contributing writer to The Gran Varones
I moved back from Orlando because I was diagnosed with HIV, I tried doing it on my own and I just couldn’t do it mentally, physically and emotionally. I just had no stability, that comfort to have somebody there. So I ended up moving back to Philly to be with my mom, my father, my family. They were my support system. They were the ones who took care of me. There were the ones who made sure I was okay with everything. I didn’t have that in Florida because I was on my own. I went to work and came home to myself. Yeah, I had friends. They knew but they did not understand; that was brand new to them. And they tried their best to support me but they just couldn’t grasp the idea of why I had HIV.
When I was first diagnosed, I wanted my parents to be the first to know. I called my mom. You could tell that she had a sense of worry. She just said “everything we be ok. We’re going to get through this together. “ From a mother to a son, I trusted her and I believed her and I sit here today.
when we started to the gran varones project, we never
imagined that the outcome would be a documentary film. in the winter of 2013,
with a no money, a few iphones, a flip cam and a shoddy microphone, we began
interviewing gay latino men from north philadelphia for a portrait photography
project. our goal was to raise the voices of gay latino men in philadelphia
telling our stories, the stories that often times get left out of the lgbtq
narrative.
in just a few months, we quickly amassed about 20 hours of film.
we knew we had to do something with the footage so we decided to download an
editing program, and learned how to use it as we edited the footage. The final
product is a 55 minute documentary of latino gay men courageously sharing their
stories and experiences.
the “our legacy is alive” documentary is a reminder that we
must tell our stories. the stonewall movie is a sobering truth that if we do
not tell and share our stories, no one will. we hope that you are inspired by
the film to share yours . we hope that this film serves as proof that our
stories can heal and brief life in our communities right here, right now. our
legacy is alive.
project coordinators:
louie a. ortiz-fonseca
anthony leon
sean laughlin
this film and project are dedicated to the courageous varones who have
so generously shared their stories in effort to raise our voices.
special thanks: gloria casarez, brent morales, charlotte sahadeo, erika
amiròn niz, nikki lopez, elicia gonzales, jaymie campbell, kira manser, samantha dato,
raices culturales latinoamericanas, concilio taller puertorriqueño and everyone
who has supported the making of this film and project.
Louie: Some of us dream about what we are going to be when we grow up, what did you want to be?
Jon David: When I was a kid, I used to play cops and robbers all the time with my cousins. When my elders would ask me what I wanted to be when I grow up, I would always say that I was going to work in the Police Department as an undercover cop! I always thought that wearing a uniform and driving my own police car would be pretty awesome! Then I lost myself and my dreams once I moved to Philadelphia from New York at the age of 7-8. We moved into a rough neighborhood and I was constantly tormented and bullied every single day in school. I had to go through many difficult life trials and tribulations to fortify myself and acquire a stronger mentality. Once I graduated high school, I was still lost and did not know what I wanted to do with my life or who I wanted to be. I even debated on joining the U.S. Army or Marines because I didn’t have any dreams left.
So many things have happened since. I can now say that I am very proud of my achievements so far. I have made my parents proud and that was very huge achievement for me. This year I have graduated college with an Associate’s Degree in Business and Communications Studies. I was then casted on a new reality show called “Saturday Morning Fever,” based on Philadelphia’s legendary television program, “Dancin’ On Air.”
Louie: Oh my god! I remember that show! I used to dream of being on there.
Jon David: The series is now in development with Fuse Network and produced by and in conjunction with Relativity Media, the very creators of the MTV Show, Catfish! Never did I think that in a matter of 4 years, I would become a coordinator and planner of events, an entertainer, and counselor to college students; let alone become involve with television and many of the cities professionals all at the age of 22!
Louie: So you’re also providing commentary on TMZ. How the hell did that happen?
Jon David: I was contacted by TMZ via Twitter and they asked me if I wanted to appear on their show and comment on one of their news stories. I was like, “Sure! I would love to.” After my first commentary on TMZ Live, they told me that I did great and would love to hear from me again. Now they call me almost every week to appear on their show via Skype and give live commentaries. I know that my journey doesn’t stop here. There are still many things for me left to do, many people for me meet and help inspire, many for me to learn from. I am eager to take life head on and I can’t wait to kick start my career this fall in preparation for the New Year!
Nick (left): Before puberty hit, I had a very squeaky voice, so I just got made fun of a lot. I remember, middle and high school, I wanted to run away. I would beg my mom to home school me. It was a dark time. It was a sad time. I was overweight. I was very insecrure, low self-esteem and it really wasn’t until I lost about 80-90 pounds, after high school and after I came out, that I really started feeling good about myself. I didn’t need to tackle being gay. I just felt good being me.
Nate (right) Coming out to my family, loved ones and friends, I was afraid. I was scared of their actions and how they would take it. That same night, I remember crying a lot, by myself before going to bed. When I woke up the next morning, I felt wonderful. I felt great. Because at that point, I was like “I don’t care if my family accepts me. I don’t care if my friends never speak to me.” I just didn’t care because it just felt great to come out. Then slowly, I started to fear becaause I started hearing stories about gay bashing. My uncle, who is also gay, got beat up. I was about 15 or 16 years old and he was put in a hopsital. I didn’t even recognize him. So that put fear in me. The fear dimmed when my parents began to accept me. If wasn’t that they accpected their gay son but rather they accpected their son who just happened to be gay.